Estate Planning for Farms, Ranches, and Oil & Gas: Tax and Succession Strategies (Pt. 2 of 2)
“Estate Planning for Farms, Ranches, and Oil & Gas: Tax and Succession Strategies (Pt. 2 of 2),” that is the subject of today’s ACTEC Trust and Estate Talk.
This is ACTEC Fellow John Challis of St. Louis, MO.
When family wealth is tied to farms, ranches, or oil and gas interests, estate planning presents unique challenges. This is part two of a two-part series. In part one, we focused on identifying and understanding these unique assets. Estate Planning for Farms, Ranches, and Oil & Gas: Tax and Succession Strategies (Pt. 1) In this part two, we will focus on how to administer and address these assets.
ACTEC Fellows Kelly Henry of Louisville, KY, Matt Hochstetler of Naples, FL, and Gene Wolf of El Paso, Texas, join us to share their expertise and help navigate these complex planning considerations. Welcome to all of you, and today we’ll start with Gene.
Gene Wolf: Well, thanks, John.
Welcome back. I hope you listen to the first podcast with Matt and Kelly to give some context and background to what we’re going to talk about today.
Every family farm, ranch and oil and gas matter that comes across my desk comes to me in one of two postures. Either the family’s still at peace and I’m designing how the land or the property will be owned or the family is already split and I’m working with whatever structure someone else is set up years ago. The law is the same in both instances, what I can do is not. What does not change is where I start. In both situations, I follow Stephen Covey’s advice of beginning with the end in mind. I look at who’s supposed to end up with what and what does the family need to look like when this is over? Only the people in the room change.
Planning Ahead for Family Farm and Ranch Succession
So, under the first scenario where the lawyers get there first, in the planning stage, designing the end means getting the whole family to the table. Generation one, the owners and controllers; generation two, those who will either run the property or cash out of it; and generation three, if they’re old enough to have a view. I want to hear from each of them before I draft a word. A structure built around what generation one assumes future generations want usually fails the first time it’s tested. You also had the ability to correct defects and title and ownership and identify assets and understand what written and oral agreements affect the property or what handshake agreements exist within the family or between neighboring landowners. Kelly described that in last week’s podcast.
The next question is what kind of farmer or ranch is this? This is something Matt talked about last week. Is it a livelihood property or is it a lifestyle property? The provisions differ, the entity choice does not. In both cases, I want a partnership and I want that partnership form now rather than a split is already on the table. So, if you’ve got a partnership between parents or children or parents and a grantor trust, I want that partnership to be a regarded entity so we get some of these next rules or the time clock running. And the reason really is timing.
Partnership Structures and Tax Considerations for Agricultural Assets
A partnership that’s been around for years is a regarded entity with a history. Property contributed to it has aged past the seven-year windows and the anti-mixing bull rules under 704(c)(1)(B) and 737. When the partnership later distributes land to one partner and cash or land to a different partner, nobody recognizes gain on appreciation they contributed years ago. In addition, the two-year disguised sale presumption under 707(a)(2)(B) has run as well.
A partnership formed five years before the family decides to divide the ranch has none of that history. And you can’t manufacture age at a later point in time. You can only start the clock early. Also, in divvying up a partnership, never forget about the hot asset rules, where depreciation recapture is triggered when you have disproportionate distributions of depreciable property.
For livelihood farms, the operative provisions are partition rights and payment terms. The children who stay and run the place need the right to take the land and the equipment itself as an undivided interest or a carved-out property, rather than being forced to buy out their siblings with cash they don’t have. This makes the inventorying that Kelly described last week so important. When a buyout is the right answer, the payment terms need to be generous; long amortization schedules, lower deferred interest, payments keyed to harvest or cattle sales, and the ability to skip a year without defaults by creating pick notes. And again, Matt went into this last week. And as he explained, farm and ranch cash flows very lumpy. A note drafted for a dental practice or some operating business will put the operator in default during the first drought, and the foreclosure will be against a sibling.
For lifestyle farms, the analysis shifts. I still want partition rights because the child who loves the place should be able to keep it. but there’s usually liquidity elsewhere in a brokerage account or an operating company. So, the agreement can direct that the sibling who leaves is paid from those assets rather from that lumpy cash flow producing land. The property stays whole and no one is dependent on that lumpy cash flow to buy the property.
Separating Mineral and Surface Rights in Estate Planning
Two provisions that go into every agreement regardless of what kind of farm or ranch it is.
- The first is the ability to separate minerals from the surface. The person who wants to farm or ranch the surface and the person who wants the royalty check are rarely the same person. If the agreement lets the partnership sever and distribute those interests separately, you have a second access along which you can divide the property fairly. If it does not, you’ve welded them together.
- The second provision that’s important is arbitration. A courthouse filing makes a family fight public and slow. Arbitration keeps it inside the family and ends it in months instead of years.
Resolving Family Disputes Over Farms, Ranches, and Oil and Gas Interests
The second scenario that comes across my desk is when the parties are already fighting. And when I’m brought in after the family has split, in my mind, the end still comes first, but the family can no longer design it together anymore. Each side has its own lawyers so the question becomes whether the professionals, after understanding what their clients want, can sit down among themselves without the clients in the room and work out what the end looks like. One sibling wants the home place, one wants cash, one wants the minerals, or maybe they all want the minerals and could really care less about the surface. If the council can agree on that picture, most of the fight is over. And what remains is the mechanics.
Then I look at how the property is held because that decides what the lawyer can do. Is it a tendency in common, a partnership, a corporation? Each comes with a different set of tools. And we don’t get to pick once the fight has started. And so, we’ve got to work within the parameters that we inherit.
If the property’s held in a partnership, the first thing I look at is the age of the partnership. If it’s been in existence long enough, the seven-year and two-year windows have closed. And I can do drop and swaps or distribute parcels in kind, generally without triggering gain. If the partnership is young, those exits can be taxable or dressed up in the way the IRS will see through. Sometimes the answer is to wait. And the agreement from scenario one would have let the family wait without litigating. Don’t forget, though, about the hot asset potential, because that’s not time dependent, that’s depreciation dependent.
If it’s tenants in common, the question is contiguity, where the co-owners hold a single track and divide it into separate parcels. That’s a partition. Each person takes what he or she already owned, and there’s no exchange that’s occurred where you have to worry about the requirements under 1031. Where the co-owners hold several non-contiguous tracks and trade undivided interests so that each one ends up with full ownership of a separate track. The IRS treats that as an exchange under 1031 and you have to qualify under 1031, walking through those rules and making sure you’ve complied with each one of them. Minerals come up here again. If the planning lawyer severed them, you have a bargaining chip. If not, you’ve got to try to divide the single asset into different ways. And again, we can partition at the dispute as long as people are working together to do this.
In the second scenario where the fight’s already begun, in the livelihood farm especially, I never forget what the land is to these people. It’s where their grandfather’s buried. It’s the house they grew up in. The tax rules decide what we as planners can do. The history, however, decides what the family will agree to. A plan that ignores either of those fails.
You know, and there’s an important concept that we’ve got to remember as we’re dividing up these properties. And that’s this idea of equal versus fair. And I think Matt’s got some great insight into that.
Balancing Fair vs. Equal Inheritances Among Farming and Non-Farming Heirs
Matt Hochstetler: Thanks, Gene. As we look to planning, estate planning for families that have more than one child, the big obstacle is figuring out what’s fair versus equal to treat all children’s inheritance. Make sure they’re all treated fairly, if not equally. More often than not, there’s not enough non-farm assets to allow every non-farm child to be treated equally with the farming child. So, we’ve got to slice and dice.
Protecting Farm Operations Through Asset Distribution and Long-Term Leases
The first thing we do is make sure the farm operating entity is its own separate entity. The farm operations shouldn’t be part of the same entity that holds the surface rights, the subsurface rights and the personal property and so forth. Have the operating entity transition to the farm child. It’s important that only the farm child have this asset because the non-farm children shouldn’t be able to meddle in the farm operations. If the value is too great, the farm child can purchase part of it for a note.
Then we look at what other assets are available to provide inheritance for the non-farm children. An easy one is putting the real estate, the surface rights, the fields, the pastures in a separate entity. And some of that or all of it can go to the non-farm children, but it should be locked up with a lease, a long-term lease with the operating entity to provide some stability in the operation. You can also use subsurface rights. It’s tempting to think of real estate encompassing both the surface and everything below the surface and everything above the surface, but you can you can separate out the rights below the surface and have those go to the non-farm children. Now, their value is going to depend on whether there are mineral deposits there, oil deposits, and whether those are going to be producing anytime soon. But it’s another way to provide some value otherwise. You can also give the non-farm children farm implements, machinery, as long as it’s available for the farm operation to continue.
And there’s also the traditional non-farm assets. There can be real estate. There can be a stock and bond portfolio. Anything else that has value, if you’re fortunate enough to have a client that has those available, which often is not the case. I think the takeaway here is when you’re structuring inheritance among a farmer’s children, be creative, separate out the assets and then try to look at what can shift value to the next generation without compromising the farm operation succeeding to the next generation. Kelly, do you have any final thoughts?
Kelly Henry: The one thing that I would add to when it comes to valuation and transferring non-farm assets to the non-farm children is going back and looking at non-farm debts. For example, what I mentioned in our last week about the debts associated with crops. Maybe when the crops have been harvested, the proceeds go to the non-farming children if it was non-farm assets that sort of financed the planting and the harvesting of the crops, or if there’s any debt associated with farm equipment, have that paid by the children in the farming operation back to the children that are not in the farming operation. That’s another way to sort of equalize things among the family.
John Challis: Thank you, Kelly, Matt, and Jean for a great discussion on these unique assets. And thank you for listening to the ACTEC Trust and Estate Talk podcast.
You may also be interested in
- Estate Planning for Farms, Ranches, and Oil & Gas: Tax and Succession Strategies (Pt. 1)
- From Art to Bitcoin: Navigating Tax Implications with ACTEC Experts – Assets come in various forms, from property to art to Bitcoin. Learn about the tax implications and nuances from the trust and estate experts at The American College of Trust and Estate Counsel.
Latest ACTEC Trust and Estate Talk Podcasts
Estate Planning for Farms, Ranches, and Oil & Gas: Tax and Succession Strategies (Pt. 1 of 2)
Explore estate planning for farms, ranches, and oil and gas interests, including asset ownership, livestock taxation, probate, and family succession.
Estate Planning for Art Collections: What Trustees and Fiduciaries Need to Know
Learn how estate planners and fiduciaries can protect and manage art collections, address authenticity and ownership risks, and navigate inheritance, museum donations, and sales.
Funding Family Offices through Profits Interests
Explore how family offices use profits interests, the Lender decision, and Sections 162 and 212 to structure compensation and address tax deductibility.


